×

Why now?

A look at why the Tama-Toledo Police Department merger was successful this time around

In a historic turn, the police departments of Tama and Toledo have merged into a single entity. This has been an idea for decades, coming closest in 2003, but it wasn’t achieved until just a few weeks ago — so why now?

To put it succinctly, Toledo Mayor Brian Sokol answered the question by saying, “The successful merger is a result of timing, hiring, and future budget concerns.”

When the subject of a merger came up in 2003, it received a lot more criticism than it did today. At the time, outgoing Toledo Police Chief Wayne Martin submitted a statement to the council in opposition to the proposal. Ex-Toledo Officer Bob Vokoun said at a council meeting in 2003, “I personally don’t think the merger would be an improvement.”

Vokoun also gave the example of the two towns failing to share a library as proof that the communities wouldn’t be able to share a police department. When asked if the personalities and personal opinions of those involved in the past led to the merger being put off for years, Sokol weighed in.

“I think that’s a fair assumption. Both cities have been overly proud at times. I think the younger generation has realized we can work together and still maintain our identity. I personally don’t see a combined city as some have speculated; it took almost 30 years to merge the police,” he said.

Kendall Jordan, the head of the new police advisory board also shared his thoughts.

“I cannot answer why this did not happen in the past. I was not involved in any of those conversations, however currently both councils are trying to conserve taxpayer dollars and save money where they can. All the officers seem to work well together and have the best for the communities in mind,” Jordan said.

Multiple factors led to the merger other than the diminishment of hubris. The exodus of officers from the Tama Police Department earlier this year, which left the department with a single officer, played a part. Officers left for a wide range of reasons, including medical leave and to pursue other opportunities; the effect this had was mainly on the rate at which everything happened.

“It certainly sped up the discussions,” Sokol said. “We had a well drafted 28E to provide reciprocal coverage, so that wasn’t an issue. It was actually drafted a few years back at Toledo’s request when we were extremely short-staffed.”

Tama Mayor Danny Robinson spoke about it from Tama’s perspective.

“At the height of the ‘exodus’ right before becoming Mayor of Tama, I did see the unfortunate downside of decisions that were made. With the dwindling staffing numbers, I felt if the logistics could back the merger, why not give it a shot? Tyler ‘A-P’ (Ayala-Pagan) and Dan Quigley have been a valuable asset in research and providing information,” he said.

It is because of the Tama Department’s staffing issues that it could be perceived that the city of Toledo is doing this to help Tama, but the cities have been helping each other out for years. “This was the core of many discussions. Currently, Toledo was fully staffed and in a great position; look back a couple years, and this was not the case,” Sokol said. “Hiring has always been difficult for police; it seems most young officers are always on the move. This was a move to help out Tama, but also an opportunity to secure a 24/7 police department for Toledo, which has always been our top priority.”

Jordan talked about this and how one town helping the other isn’t new.

“Toledo and Tama both will see savings in their current public safety budgets. It could be perceived as one town helping the other; however, since I have been around, one or the other have been short officers here and there. Tama helped Toledo for a while a couple of years ago while Toledo was short-handed, and up until this merger Toledo was helping Tama out,” he said. “The communities are separated by a line on the map, and this just makes sense to work together. So what does Toledo get out of this merger, hopefully a sustainable local police department with 24/7 coverage for the residents, which is the same thing Tama will get.”

Robinson talked about how all will benefit.

“I can see how this could be perceived as Toledo ‘helping out.’ However, both Departments are benefiting greatly, not only being able to share resources and equipment but especially when it comes to cost-effective measures to control budget numbers and whatnot to provide continued sustainability of the police presence in the community,” he said.

Money may have been the biggest factor in the contemplation of the merger.

“For Toledo, Public Safety is our largest budget item. Future restrictions being forced down from the state level will be especially hard on smaller rural cities with limited growth. Toledo’s financial position is strong, but we know that could change quickly in the future,” Sokol said. “We have a conservative council, clerk, and city administrator that works hard and is always forward thinking. I would expect this is the first of many future consolidations not only for Toledo but other small communities as well.”

Jordan also provided a financial perspective.

“Public safety is primarily paid for out of the general fund, which is getting harder to pull money from given the new property tax reform,” he said. “The city councils continue to find ways to tighten the budget, and both cities will save money merging the police departments.”

Robinson said the reason finances played a large role in the merger was for one simple reason.

“The sustainability of the police department for our community. Not only are we seeing within the state but nationwide, towns of our size are either dissolving the departments or they are merging,” he said.

The number of officers the new department would employ was a compromise due to multiple elements, including scheduling requirements. The department will have nine full-time officers, two of which are new hires. As both police departments have struggled with staffing and perception issues, the merger is hoped to alleviate some.

Sokol looked at the issue realistically, saying that it’s still a relatively small department that has to deal with ever-shrinking candidate pools. However, Jordan stated that the merger will make things less of a challenge.

“It may be easier to draw additional quality officers to the area, being a larger department now,” he said.

“It’s a bigger police force with a larger area to work within. Just from the applicants and current staff, that has been the two leading factors why the merger has attracted more interest in joining the department,” Robinson added.

The new department will be overseen by the new Advisory Board, which is an equal joint venture. The board is made up of two council members from both cities, both mayors, and Jordan, the Toledo city administrator, heading up the group.

“We will be having regular meetings until everything gets rolling well. Then we will evaluate the frequency of the meetings. Overall, we hit the road running, and the merger went very smooth,” Jordan said.

Although a few kinks of the transition still have to be worked out, the merger is completed and the Tama-Toledo Police Department has been born.

“This certainly should be a proud moment for the community. There will be bumps in the road as we move forward, but this merger was well thought out, creating an advisory board of both towns. Both towns get to keep their name on the Police Department, which was important to keep their identity. Think of it as being conservatively progressive,” Sokol said.

“This will work well because both cities have committed to make this work. This is a huge step forward for our communities as we continue to look for ways to save money and improve our public safety,” Jordan added. “Everyone should be proud that this has happened. The residents should be confident this will work due to the effort and time spent on evaluating all the aspects of this merger by the councils, the advisory board, and the police officers. There surely will be some bumps along the way, but I feel we can work them out.”

“Faith and Pride are two closely related things. Faith is the action; pride is the emotion you feel when you have faith. Similar to what JFK had once said, this isn’t about what the community can do for you but rather what you can do for your community,” Robinson said. “The citizens’ support with Faith and Pride for the merger has been undoubtedly unwavering, and could not have asked for a better community to serve. So why should the community be proud and confident in the merger? It was their support that had a great role in the establishment of the merger.”

The merging of the Tama and Toledo Police Departments has been 23 years in the making. Good things take time, it seems. And remember, it’s still early days; the department hasn’t even begun to fly yet.

Or as Mayor Robinson put it, “For now, we are running down the TarMac, taking flight: ‘Paso Corto, Vista Larga!’ (Short steps, long vision).” With this historic step, we grow together a little more as a community, and that just makes sense. Just like Jordan put it, “The communities are separated by a line on the map, and this just makes sense to work together.”